Apple announced towards the end of last year that it was dropping the Xserve – it’s rack mounted server that runs OS X Server. Although Apple hasn’t given a specific reason, a lot of people are saying it’s because the Mac Pro and Mac Mini are quite capable alternatives to the Xserve. And this sounds very sensible to me.
Rack mount servers are used in large organisations where you need a lot of server power and need to save space. But in this kind of environment you would be unlikely to find every user on the network to be using a Mac – they’re likely to be on Windows and if not, more likely to be on Linux than all on Macs. So if most users are on Windows or Linux, the rack mount servers are likely to be running either Windows or Linux (or Unix). I can’t see anyone wanting to pay the extra for an Xserve to use in a mixed network.
So the Xserve is only likely to be used in an environment where most of the machines on the network are Macs and they want a central server for file sharing and other services that can be easily set up and used. There are a few problems with this as well though. Firstly, in this environment – most likely creative studios – there’s only likely to be ten or twenty client machines so the only piece of equipment that would be rack mountable would be the Xserve. Secondly, it’s not likely that a network of this size would require the hardware provided by an Xserve to meet their needs. That’s why most people are saying that the effectiveness of the Mac Pro or Mac Mini as server hardware when the server software is available for these (and other) hardware configurations, is a sensible way to go. It saves on hardware costs, fits in with their office network setups and in some cases the Mac in question can be used as someones desktop machine – we used our old Mac Mini running Server as a way of showing clients websites on the board room TV!
I like that Apple hasn’t tried to push the Xserve onto existing customers but let in die in favour of letting us use what we want to use. This fits with the way I’ve set up networks in the past (confession time). I’m actually relatively new to the Mac world – I’ve been using them since I started working here about 8 months ago. Before that it was Windows and Linux. In most of the past networks I’ve been in charge of I’ve opted for using Linux on a relatively cheap and low spec PC to provide network services instead of getting expensive dedicated hardware. At the last place I was at we had an ex-display Campaq desktop from Dixons bought for £70 and it’s been running Linux and doing it’s job for about 6 years.
So good bye Xserve – I am slightly gutted I never convinced any of my managers to let me have one but that’s OK. Next week I’ll be getting one of our old iMacs that isn’t useful any more and installing Snow Leopard Server on it.